[ishiwgao]

it looks like a cool build!

Not to spoil the fun though, my first impressions were "are you sure you wanna use battery boxes as front and rear crash structures...?"

 

[brian_]

View attachment 124224

...
Motor (output shaft) is bolted directly to the differential (pinion shaft, I'll need to get a coupler made). Changed ring and pinion gears to match motor RPM limit with, I don't know, 90mph? Looks like I need to use a front diff, to avoid problems with oil flow, since I have the diff oriented backwards. Not sure exactly which would be best. Definitely need an LSD. And one of the bigger problems is a lot of front diffs are significantly more lopsided than rear diffs, but possibly due to removable stub axles?

Whether they are live beam axles or final drives for independent front suspension, those front axles are only offset so that the propeller shaft can clear the engine. You can use the same centre section in a non-offset configuration. You might also not need a specifically front unit - the differential internals are the same, and some ring-and-pinion sets can run either way.

 

[brian_]

View attachment 124222 View attachment 124224
View attachment 124225

...

And mock up the cabin and see if my girlfriend and I fit.

I understand the tandem seating arrangement, but there's no one I would want and be able to sit with this way. You may find it works, but a serious mockup (with sides, not just two spots marked on the floor) would certainly be required.

 

[brian_]

Not to spoil the fun though, my first impressions were "are you sure you wanna use battery boxes as front and rear crash structures...?"

Perhaps just an energy-absorbing nose cone would be a wise addition.

 

[brian_]

Everything fun seems to use a NetGain Warp 9 motor.

That may have been true several years ago.

 

[Darxus]

it looks like a cool build!

Not to spoil the fun though, my first impressions were "are you sure you wanna use battery boxes as front and rear crash structures...?"

Thank you. Yup, safety is not a high priority in this design. I figure it's significantly safer than my motorcycle, and I'm comfortable with that.

Whether they are live beam axles or final drives for independent front suspension, those front axles are only offset so that the propeller shaft can clear the engine. You can use the same centre section in a non-offset configuration. You might also not need a specifically front unit - the differential internals are the same, and some ring-and-pinion sets can run either way.

That is very helpful, thank you. Do you know of any specific examples that would work? Or how best to find them?

Seems like something that came with an LSD would be nice, but maybe not, since I need to change the gear ratio anyway. It would also be nice to use a rear diff that can handle the rotation / oil flow, so I can use the original axles (without removing the stub shaft(?)).

Are there any with a centered pinion, equal length half shafts, and an offset ring gear? (Not important, but I'm curious, I like symmetry.)

I understand the tandem seating arrangement, but there's no one I would want and be able to sit with this way. You may find it works, but a serious mockup (with sides, not just two spots marked on the floor) would certainly be required.

Yeah, I'm thinking just passengers I'd ride a motorcycle with. And definitely need a mockup with walls and a roof.

That may have been true several years ago.

Can you give me examples that are fun without a Warp 9 motor now? Other than snowdog's electric supercar, with a Tesla subframe, which I believe would be too wide for this body, and cost $56,499.37 for the build as of March?

 

[brian_]

Can you give me examples that are fun without a Warp 9 motor now? Other than snowdog's electric supercar, with a Tesla subframe, which I believe would be too wide for this body, and cost $56,499.37 for the build as of March?

There are many swaps using Tesla drive units or any other common modern EV (e.g. Leaf), and all will have more power available than any WarP 9 can produce; they don't need to be as expensive as snowdog's car, but none will be the $1,000 that some people seem to think an EV can be built for with a free forklift motor, homebuilt controller, and some miracle deal on a salvaged battery.

 

[brian_]

Seems like something that came with an LSD would be nice, but maybe not, since I need to change the gear ratio anyway.

Since the same ring and pinion gears worth with limited-slip and open differentials of the same final drive model, you can change the ratio without losing the LSD. You can also find something with the right ratio and replace the open diff with a limited-slip, but it would have to have a limited-slip available.

 

[Electric Land Cruiser]

It's not my style but it looks like fun! I say build it but I agree I'd go with a modern EV motor. Maybe LEAF motor and transaxle with custom controller. The LEAF motor is small and 100-150lbs or something so pretty light. Can make 300+kw with custom inverter (and the right batteries).

 

[Rusted B&B]

this is pretty cool concept - I like the fighter jet style seating but I would do a mach up of the fitment of the seating but design an real are very different. I tried this and was like, oh, that is way to close.

 

[Darxus]

There are many swaps using Tesla drive units or any other common modern EV (e.g. Leaf), and all will have more power available than any WarP 9 can produce; they don't need to be as expensive as snowdog's car, but none will be the $1,000 that some people seem to think an EV can be built for with a free forklift motor, homebuilt controller, and some miracle deal on a salvaged battery.

Thank you. Is there any way to get a Limited Slip Differential with a Leaf motor?

 

[Electric Land Cruiser]

Thank you. Is there any way to get a Limited Slip Differential with a Leaf motor?

Yes Quaife has quoted people for some amount of money I forget. I would pull one apart and measure the parts it may be the same or close enough to something available for other Nissan FWDs that would be less expensive.

 

[brian_]

Are there any with a centered pinion, equal length half shafts, and an offset ring gear? (Not important, but I'm curious, I like symmetry.)

Looking for examples, it appears that all conventional (not high pinion) front differentials have the ring and pinion gears cut the same as at the rear, so a rear unit can simply be turned around (and the motor rotational direction set appropriately). Typically rear final drive units are set up for equal-length half-shafts and a centred pinion shaft.

In a discussion of Dennis Palatov's 2019 Pikes Peak Racecar, we had a look at the complete chassis:

...
A 2020 article mentioned that the car was run on the salt flat at Bonneville (in 2019) and included this interesting view of the D2EV without bodywork or battery packs:

I'm reasonably certain that the front final drive unit is normally used at the rear, and is simply turned and placed in the front. Some members of this forum worked on that car, so they might know what was used, but as far as I know they were not on the mechanical side.

 

[MattsAwesomeStuff]

but none will be the $1,000

1000 euro was the challenge. Bit more wiggle room.

I could really use some more people telling me "That looks fun, you should build it."

Doesn't matter what we think, if you think it looks fun, then go build it. It's certainly different, which means, maybe almost no one would think it's cool except you. That's okay, you build the car that's perfect for you, not us.

The Soliton 1 became unavailable, the Zilla 1k came back.

So... Damien threw together a quick 1000+ amp DC mod board for the stupidly-cheap salvaged Prius Gen 2 controller ($150 at most, lots are grabbing them for $50).

Though, he never really finalized or produced the design. EV8 over on the OpenInverter forums was smart enough to read that design and build a quick sample board of it on some perfboard... without writing any of it down, just keeping it all in his head. I think he stuck it into his RX8, and was disappointed by only 265 hp out of it or somesuch before he I think melted his motor or something (controller was fine). He's moved onto an AC build now.

So a couple of us said "Stop, wait... can you share what you built?" and he's too busy to get around to doing it, said he'd have to write it all down. So I was like "No, just, share what you did, whatever you used to build it" and he was like "Oh, I just built it in my head". And then with some slight nagging, he's come around to "Okay fine, didn't think anyone was still doing DC builds... I'll try to get around to it sometime after the next couple weeks." That was, yesterday.

Anyway, point being, for something close to almost free, you can repurpose a Prius Gen 2 inverter and go melt a motor if you want to, depending on how good you are about reading schematics or, how patient you are and gambling that EV8 will find time to publish something more crowd-friendly.

Everything fun seems to use a NetGain Warp 9 motor.

Don't pay for a Warp 9. Use a forklift motor if that's where you're at. Pretty much same thing, and you can get one for ~$150 in scrap value, (I got several for free). Some people say they have trouble finding these, but, I'd say the massive majority are still able to do so without much hassle at all. Call up forklift repair places in your city, ask if they have any old traction motors around "Just in case" that you could buy from them, or any junkers in the yard you could pull the motor off yourself. There's a massive 130-page thread in the motor forums here about how to do this.

Seems to me you can easily get both motor and controller for a DC build for well under $500. Under $200 if you're persuasive.

 

[Darxus]

Looking for examples, it appears that all conventional (not high pinion) front differentials have the ring and pinion gears cut the same as at the rear, so a rear unit can simply be turned around (and the motor rotational direction set appropriately). Typically rear final drive units are set up for equal-length half-shafts and a centred pinion shaft.

In a discussion of Dennis Palatov's 2019 Pikes Peak Racecar, we had a look at the complete chassis:

I'm reasonably certain that the front final drive unit is normally used at the rear, and is simply turned and placed in the front. Some members of this forum worked on that car, so they might know what was used, but as far as I know they were not on the mechanical side.

That's great, thank you. So I should be able to use a Ford 8.8" rear diff, which seems very popular for custom things, just oriented as a front diff? Its pinion is horizontally offset by 2", are you considering that centered?

Wow, I used to follow Palatov's stuff a lot when he was working on the DP1, I had no idea he won Pikes Peak a bunch of times.

 

[brian_]

So I should be able to use a Ford 8.8" rear diff, which seems very popular for custom things, just oriented as a front diff?

Yes, that's in most Ford cars with IRS, RWD/AWD, and a longitudinal engine. There is a range of ring-and-pinion sets for it to change the ratio. Stronger versions built since 2015 are called the "Super 8.8"; some parts are not interchangeable between the versions (apparently pinion bearing etc. for the "super" come from the Ford 9.75 unit) so get the one you want from the beginning. The Mustang has used a Super 8.8 with IRS since 2015. It comes in both aluminum and iron housings.

Its pinion is horizontally offset by 2", are you considering that centered?

Yes, that's what I was thinking of as close enough. There's no good reason for an auto designer to require the propeller shaft to be exactly centred, so I'm not surprised that they vary by that much.

 

[MesquiteTim]

A miata donor, or at least the rear sub frame with diff and suspension would be MUCH easier to start with than a Ford rear end. Check out the Exocet for clues. The electric motor could be directly coupled to the diff and still be behind the rear seat

 

[Darxus]

Yes, that's in most Ford cars with IRS, RWD/AWD, and a longitudinal engine. There is a range of ring-and-pinion sets for it to change the ratio. Stronger versions built since 2015 are called the "Super 8.8"; some parts are not interchangeable between the versions (apparently pinion bearing etc. for the "super" come from the Ford 9.75 unit) so get the one you want from the beginning. The Mustang has used a Super 8.8 with IRS since 2015. It comes in both aluminum and iron housings.

Yes, that's what I was thinking of as close enough. There's no good reason for an auto designer to require the propeller shaft to be exactly centred, so I'm not surprised that they vary by that much.

Great, thank you. Yeah, I had a feeling. In such a narrow bodied and symmetrical car, it's noticable, but I can cope. You can't see it because this quick render has a black background, but the offset gives me a fine place to tuck the charger.

A miata donor, or at least the rear sub frame with diff and suspension would be MUCH easier to start with than a Ford rear end. Check out the Exocet for clues. The electric motor could be directly coupled to the diff and still be behind the rear seat

Many possibilities in life would be much easier than attempting this project. But using the Miata rear suspension... would not give me the inboard coilovers I want. I want to do the suspension much like an FSAE car (with outboard brakes).

But I do often think about building a regular locost 7 or T-bucket for practice.

 

[brian_]

A miata donor, or at least the rear sub frame with diff and suspension would be MUCH easier to start with than a Ford rear end. Check out the Exocet for clues.

Yes, it would be easier, but the Miata subframe would be wide compared to the desired body; the Exocet is not a narrow tandem-seat vehicle.

The electric motor could be directly coupled to the diff and still be behind the rear seat

Yes, but the final drive unit would be facing the wrong way... although the suspension with an early Miata subframe would probably be usable turned around.